The Stem Cell Spin
It was bound to happen. When Congress passed H.R. 810 - the Stem Cell Research Enhancement Act - everyone knew President Bush was going to invoke the first veto of his Presidency. From there Congress was unable to garner the votes in order to override the veto and so the war of spin has begun again. As always some commentators, either through ignorance or just the plain ignoring of the facts, have decided to spin this story in an interesting way.
Two days ago Rush Limbaugh said that embryonic stem cells come only from abortions. Which was news to me because from my understanding the embryonic stem cells in question came from fertilization clinics which, last I checked, assists people in becoming pregnant, not the other way around. I’m not trying to be a typical Limbaugh basher but when a wildly popular radio host says something like this he tells millions of U.S. citizens something that is flat-out false. Even when given as a simple opinion it grossly ignores the truth and takes away from the honest moral debate on stem cells.
What has bothered me immensely with this subject is the fact that conservative talk hosts have taken this topic and distorted the facts in an effort to give more power to their argument. Another example: for the past two days radio show and CNN Headline News host Glenn Beck chimed in on the topic on both his radio and TV show stating that he doesn’t want the practice of fetal farming to emerge and he strongly hinted that he doesn’t trust doctors will maintain this ethical line when given federal funding.
All of this is a valid point but only without knowledge that the stem cell bills included two measures that banned fetal farming. In fact H.R. 810 actually creates stricter ethical guidelines then what is already allowed by Bush's 2001 compromise on stem cells. Why has this little fact gone unnoticed? Furthermore federal funding was to be exclusive to stem cell research using embryos from fertility clinics that would otherwise be discarded. Senator Tom Harkin (D-IA) stated earlier today on the Ed Schultz radio show that donors of the embryos would be given the option of donating the left over embryos not being used in fertility clinics to science. Donors could also opt to not have their embryos used in which case they would be discarded just like unused embryos right now.
I see the other side of the argument. Many Americans are bringing up the point that this research should be left to the private sector and pharmaceutical companies should be allowed to continue their own exploration of stem cells. The idea being that taxpayers shouldn’t be forced to pay for something they don’t all agree upon. (I would point out taxpayers pay for a good deal of what they don’t support.) But why shouldn't the federal government support research that holds so much promise to better the lives of American citizens? Polls show the heavy majority of Americans do support federal funding for stem cell research. With a majority somewhere in the range of 70% of the country political opponents of H.R. 810 may take a hit at the polls in November.
I also find it interesting that some of President Bush’s supporters have defended his compromise on stem cells back in 2001 when Bush permitted federal funding of research but only on the estimated 60 stem cells lines that existed before August 9, 2001. I would question why Bush found it morally acceptable to fund research on stem cells created before August 9, 2001 and not after. What exactly changed after August 9 of that year and what gives the President this moral authority to decide what stem cells are untouchable and which stem cells are just fine for federal funding? Why wasn't the cut-off August 10? Or August 15? If the President does feel so strongly about this topic why were any stem cell lines approved for federal funding? In the opinion of this modest observer this marks a significant inconsistency in the President’s policy. Stem cell research is sure to be a hot topic come mid-term elections in November.
Labels: Politics
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home