Tuesday, October 24, 2006

The New Separate But Equal?

I have been staying away from writing political articles lately simply because I don't have the time to do the proper research these days. Something I read today has changed that trend because I am extremely skeptical of a new federal rule that will back the creation of more single-sex public schools. Just today the Bush administration has given the Education Department new latitude to expand not just single-sex classes but also single-sex schools.

As a proud product of the New Jersey public school system. I acknowledge that there are serious issues within our nation's public education but some of the solutions I have seen presented in recent years do not answer any of the concerns I had while going through my 12 years of public schooling. This new change now calls for more separation between young boys and girls in the classroom so long as the school districts taking part in this make coeducational schools and classes of “substantially equal” quality available to the excluded sex. Where have we heard this type of language before, maybe Brown v. Board of Education?

I don't believe in the concept of something being "substantially equal." Will females in one class have the exact same teacher as their fellow males in their version of the same class? Will the class be able to move at the same pace and will the same material be covered over the course of the school year? Even if both of these questions are answered with a yes it begs the question as to why we need to separate boys and girls in the first place.

The bottom line is if we don't tolerate the concept of separate but equal for dividing students according to race then why should it be any different for gender? The concept simply makes no sense to me, especially given the fact that supporters of single-sex schools even concede the fact that they have had mixed results with only a few studies showing possible positive effects. I'm sorry but that's just not enough to convince me to toss Title IX and the equal protection clause out the window.

My opposition to this concept is that I believe this will create an even deeper divide between the thinking of men and women. Already most of this country is convinced that boys and girls don't think alike while completely ignoring the fact that males and females are raised in very different ways in our culture. As I've pointed out in other blog entries, with loads of evidence, the manner in which America is raising its daughters is downright dangerous. The same can be said for the way we our raising our boys, but for different reasons. The last thing we need now is to worsen this condition by separating the two sexes and creating a very different experience for our children.

Growing up with girls in my classroom made me interact and become comfortable around the opposite sex. If I had grown up in a classroom with only boys I'm sure my attitude and experience with women would be very different. This is not the problem with our public school system. We need to develop better ways to engage students and to make them understand success in the classroom translates to success in life. Why are schools protective of student's GPAs? If my grades had been posted on the front of the school with my class ranking listed right next to it you better believe I would have cared a whole lot more about academics. Give students more control over what they are learning. I left high school with absolutely no idea what I was doing with my life and it took years of college in order to even get a clue about all the opportunities that exist in the workforce. Why didn't my years in high school prepare me, even remotely, for this enormous step in my life? This is the failure of our public school system.

The gender divide in certain topics comes as much from teacher bias as it does from anything else. The creation of single-sex schools will do nothing more then drive away members of the sex that are not dominant within a certain field. Shouldn't boys and girls be taught to compete with each other? You know, just like how it works in real life. For the time being I'm going to side with the opponents to these rule changes because the separation of men and women in the classroom is no better then the separation of different races in the classroom. But that's just the opinion of this modest observer.

Labels:

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home